Lou remembers the first time he truly felt shame. He was in the fifth grade, and the class was having a math quiz. Math wasn’t his strong suit, but Lou had studied hard the night before, determined to do well. The next day, as the teacher handed back the graded quizzes, Lou was hopeful. But when he saw the big, red “D” at the top of his paper, his heart sank. His classmates began comparing their grades, and as they asked to see Lou’s, he tried to hide it. But one of them snatched the paper out of his hands and shouted, “Look! He got a D!” The room erupted in laughter. Lou felt his face flush with heat, his chest tighten, and he wanted to disappear. It wasn’t just embarrassment he felt—it was something deeper.
It was shame.
Shame isn’t just about feeling bad; it’s about feeling that you, as a person, are somehow less because of what happened. In that moment, Lou wasn’t just upset about his grade. He felt like that “D” was a reflection of his worth, like it somehow meant he wasn’t smart or good enough. Shame is different from guilt. Guilt is what you feel when you know you’ve done something wrong, like telling a lie or hurting someone’s feelings. Guilt is tied to your actions, and it can push you to make things right. But shame? Shame is when you internalize those actions and believe they make you a bad person.
For days after that math quiz, Lou carried that feeling with him. Lou avoided participating in class, convinced that everyone thought he was dumb. Lou’s self-confidence took a hit, all because he let that one moment define who he thought he was. It wasn’t until much later that Lou learned how to separate his actions from his self-worth. One bad grade didn’t mean Lou was a failure; it just meant Lou had room to grow. But that’s the tricky thing about shame—it can be sneaky, whispering lies that you’re not enough, that you don’t measure up. And if you’re not careful, those whispers can become the stories you tell yourself.
Shame is a complex emotion that everyone experiences at some point, just like Lou. We are all familiar with it to some degree, but it’s less commonly known that not all shame is created equal. There are two types: healthy shame and unhealthy shame. Understanding the difference between the two can help you manage your emotions better and lead a more fulfilling life.
What Is Healthy Shame?
Healthy shame is a natural and constructive emotion. It acts as an internal compass, guiding us to recognize when we’ve crossed a line, violated a moral code, or hurt someone. This type of shame helps us learn from our mistakes and encourages personal growth. For example, if you’ve hurt a friend with an unkind comment, feeling ashamed can lead you to apologize and repair the relationship.
Healthy shame is tied to specific actions rather than to your entire sense of self. It’s a temporary feeling that helps you align your behavior with your values. Once you’ve made amends or learned from the situation, healthy shame dissipates, allowing you to move on.
What Is Unhealthy Shame?
Unhealthy shame, on the other hand, is pervasive and toxic. It’s not just about feeling bad for something you’ve done; it’s about feeling fundamentally flawed as a person. Unhealthy shame can stem from past trauma, negative experiences, or critical messages you received growing up. Instead of being tied to a specific action, it becomes a part of your identity.
Unhealthy shame tells you that you are not enough, that you are unworthy of love, respect, or success. It can lead to a cycle of negative self-talk, self-sabotage, and even depression or anxiety. Unlike healthy shame, unhealthy shame doesn’t dissipate after the situation is resolved. Instead, it lingers, affecting your self-esteem and overall well-being.
How to Identify Whether You’re Experiencing Healthy or Unhealthy Shame
Knowing whether you’re dealing with healthy or unhealthy shame is crucial for managing your emotions effectively. Here are some key differences to help you identify which one you’re experiencing:
- Focus on Behavior vs. Focus on Self
– Healthy Shame: You feel bad about a specific action or behavior, not about who you are as a person. For example, you might think, “I made a mistake,” rather than “I am a mistake.”
– Unhealthy Shame: The focus is on your entire self. You might have thoughts like, “I’m a terrible person,” or “I’m worthless,” which indicate that the shame is not just about your actions but about your identity.
- Temporary vs. Persistent
– Healthy Shame: The feeling is usually short-lived. Once you’ve made amends or corrected your behavior, the shame subsides.
– Unhealthy Shame: The feeling persists long after the event has passed. It may even resurface in unrelated situations, reinforcing a negative self-image.
- Motivating vs. Paralyzing
– Healthy Shame: It motivates you to change, apologize, or improve. It’s a catalyst for growth and learning.
– Unhealthy Shame: It can be paralyzing, leading to avoidance, withdrawal, or self-destructive behaviors. Instead of prompting positive change, it keeps you stuck in a cycle of negativity.
- Linked to Values vs. Linked to Negative Self-Beliefs
– Healthy Shame: It’s aligned with your values and moral compass. You feel shame because you’ve acted against your principles, and you want to make things right.
– Unhealthy Shame: It’s often linked to deep-seated negative beliefs about yourself, which may have been ingrained over time by past experiences, criticism, or trauma.
How to Manage and Navigate Out of Unhealthy Shame
If you’ve identified that you’re experiencing unhealthy shame, it’s important to take steps to manage and overcome it. Here are some strategies to help you navigate out of unhealthy shame and move toward a healthier emotional state:
- Recognize and Acknowledge Your Shame
The first step is to recognize when you’re feeling shame and acknowledge it. Pay attention to your thoughts and feelings when shame arises. Are you criticizing yourself harshly? Are you feeling unworthy or flawed? Identifying these patterns is the first step toward change.
- Challenge Negative Self-Talk
Unhealthy shame often manifests as negative self-talk. It’s important to challenge these thoughts when they arise. Ask yourself if the thoughts are based on facts or if they’re distorted by your shame. For example, instead of thinking, “I’m a failure,” reframe it as, “I made a mistake, but I can learn from it.”
- Practice Self-Compassion
Treat yourself with the same kindness and understanding that you would offer a friend. Self-compassion involves recognizing that everyone makes mistakes and that you are not alone in your struggles. Practice speaking to yourself in a gentle, supportive way, and remind yourself that your worth is not defined by your mistakes.
- Seek Support
Sometimes, overcoming unhealthy shame requires external support. This could be from a trusted friend, a therapist, or a support group. Sharing your feelings with someone who can offer empathy and perspective can be incredibly healing. A therapist can help you explore the root causes of your shame and develop strategies to overcome it.
- Reframe Your Narrative
Unhealthy shame often stems from a narrative you’ve internalized about yourself. Reframe this narrative by focusing on your strengths, achievements, and positive qualities. Start by writing down things you like about yourself or things you’ve accomplished, no matter how small. Over time, this can help shift your focus from your perceived flaws to your true worth.
- Engage in Activities That Build Self-Esteem
Participating in activities that make you feel competent and valued can help counteract unhealthy shame. This could be anything from volunteering, pursuing a hobby, or setting and achieving small goals. Building your self-esteem through positive actions can gradually weaken the hold of unhealthy shame.
- Practice Mindfulness and Grounding Techniques
Mindfulness practices can help you stay present and reduce the power of negative emotions like shame. Techniques such as deep breathing, meditation, or grounding exercises can help you stay connected to the present moment and reduce the intensity of shame when it arises.
- Focus on Growth and Learning
Shift your focus from perfection to growth. Understand that mistakes and failures are a natural part of life and learning. Instead of seeing them as evidence of your inadequacy, view them as opportunities to grow and improve. This mindset can help reduce the impact of unhealthy shame and foster a healthier relationship with yourself.
Conclusion
Shame is a powerful emotion that can either guide you toward personal growth or trap you in a cycle of self-doubt and negativity. By understanding the difference between healthy and unhealthy shame, you can take steps to manage your emotions and develop a more positive self-image. Remember, everyone makes mistakes, but those mistakes do not define your worth. With the right tools and support, you can navigate out of unhealthy shame and move toward a more fulfilling and compassionate life.
To schedule an appointment with OnePatient, contact info@onepatient.org.
